Best Toaster Oven for Pizza: Five Picks for Pizza Night
Five toaster ovens picked for pizza night: a smart Breville, a two-pizza Hamilton Beach, a wide Black+Decker, a French-door Elite Gourmet, and an easy-reach Hamilton Beach.
It is Tuesday, and there is a frozen pizza box on the counter. The kids are hungry, the evening is short, and the big oven wants fifteen minutes just to warm up for a meal that takes twenty minutes to cook. You look at the box, then at the oven, then at the clock. The best toaster oven for pizza ends that argument. A small oven heats in minutes, the pizza slides in, and dinner comes out with a crisp base while the big oven stays cold. This page is my guide to toaster oven pizza: how I picked the best toaster oven for pizza night in our house, and the five ovens I would buy first.
A toaster oven is a small oven that sits on the counter. Heating elements top and bottom warm the air inside, and a fan in the better ones moves that air around the food. For pizza, that small box is an advantage, not a compromise. The heat is close to the food, the base crisps fast, and the cheese melts before the crust dries out. A toaster oven pizza night is faster, cooler, and cheaper to run than heating the full oven for one pie. If you are choosing your first toaster oven of any kind, my guide to the best toaster ovens covers the whole category. This page is for one job only: pizza.
One honest note before we start: this page has affiliate links. If you buy through one, the site may earn a small commission. It costs you nothing, and it never decides what I recommend. Prices here are as of Nov 18, 2026, and prices move, so check the current price before you buy anything.
Top 3 picks
- Breville Smart Oven BOV800XL — Best overall for pizza. A 13-inch fit, a pizza preset, and smart heat control that balances the top and bottom elements for a crisp base. Check on Amazon
- Hamilton Beach 31103DA Countertop Oven with Rotisserie — Best for two pizzas at once. Two 12-inch pizzas on two racks, so everyone eats at the same time. Check on Amazon
- BLACK+DECKER TO3250XSB 8-Slice Extra Wide — Best value. A 12-inch pizza, eight slices, and a 9-by-13 pan with handles, for less than the rest of this page. Check on Amazon
How I picked these
I cook every day for a family of four, and Tuesday is pizza night in our house more weeks than not. Sometimes the pizza comes out of the freezer. Sometimes it is last night's leftovers, reheated for lunch. Either way, the oven has one job: a crisp base, melted cheese, and a hot middle, without heating the whole kitchen for one pie. I did not run these five ovens through a lab, and I will not pretend I did. I picked them from verified specs, maker details, and what daily cooking teaches about what an oven has to survive: a frozen pizza slid in straight from the freezer, a tray pulled out one-handed, a door opened with an oven mitt, and a counter with no space to spare.
An oven earns a place on this page if it does four things. It fits the pizza people actually buy, which is 12 inches across. It heats from below as well as from above, because a pizza base crisps from underneath. It reaches the temperature a frozen pizza box asks for, which is usually 400°F to 450°F. And it lets you get the pizza out safely, without burning your hands on a hot door. Scores are my own judgement, not a copied rating.
One thing I checked on every pick is the pizza size, in inches, from the maker's own listing. "Fits a pizza" means nothing on its own. An 11-inch fit and a 12-inch fit are a different pizza night. The honest 11-inch note is below, because one good oven on this page fits 11 inches and not 12, and you should know that before you buy it.
The best toaster ovens for pizza at a glance
| Product | Pizza fit | Power | Best for | Check on Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Breville Smart Oven BOV800XL | 13-inch pizza | 1,800 W | Best overall for pizza | Check on Amazon |
| Hamilton Beach 31103DA Rotisserie | Two 12-inch pizzas | 1,500 W | Best for two pizzas at once | Check on Amazon |
| BLACK+DECKER TO3250XSB Extra Wide | 12-inch pizza | 1,500 W | Best value | Check on Amazon |
| Elite Gourmet ETO-4510M French Door | Two 14-inch pizzas | 1,800 W | Best for large pizzas | Check on Amazon |
| Hamilton Beach 31123DA Easy Reach | 12-inch pizza | 1,400 W | Best easy-access door | Check on Amazon |
The one I would buy first
Pizza is the food that shows what a toaster oven can really do, and the Breville Smart Oven is the toaster oven other toaster ovens get compared to. The reason is the heat. Five quartz elements, three on top and two underneath, with a system Breville calls Element IQ that adjusts the power to each element on its own. Pizza gets more heat from the bottom, where the base needs it. Toast gets more from the top. The oven works out the balance for the food you picked, instead of blasting the same heat at everything. That is why it browns evenly, and even browning is the whole job with a pizza.
There is a pizza preset, one of nine. Press it and the oven sets the temperature and the element balance for a pizza, and the convection fan moves the hot air around the food so the edges and the middle cook at the same pace. The interior fits a 13-inch pizza, which is an inch more than a standard frozen pizza needs. That inch matters. It is the air gap around the pie that lets the hot air reach the crust, instead of the pizza wedging against the walls. An LCD screen shows the temperature and the time, and an interior light comes on so you can watch the cheese melt without opening the door and losing the heat.
The weakness is size and weight. It is about 19 inches wide and weighs 18.7 pounds. It needs a permanent home on the counter, with a few inches of air around it. It is not a machine you lift into a cupboard. For a family that cooks pizza in it most weeks, that trade is worth it. This is the oven I would buy first, and the one I would hand to anyone buying a toaster oven for pizza.
One thing to know about the inside. The Breville's cavity has a non-stick coating, stated on Breville's own listing. That is normal for a toaster oven, and the coating is stable at pizza temperatures. If coatings are the deciding question for your kitchen, my guide to the best non-toxic toaster ovens covers the ovens without one.
The one for two pizzas at once
One pizza feeds four people if everyone is polite about it. Two pizzas feed four people with leftovers, and leftovers are tomorrow's lunch. The problem with one pizza at a time is the second batch. The first pizza goes cold while the second one cooks, or the first half of the family eats while the second half waits. The Hamilton Beach 31103DA ends that problem by fitting two 12-inch pizzas at once, on two racks, in one big box.
The box is the biggest here in the way that matters for pizza night. Two pizzas, two 9-by-13 casseroles, or two cake pans fit at the same time. The convection setting moves the hot air around both racks, so the top pizza and the bottom pizza cook at the same pace. A two-hour timer with auto shutoff covers a long bake, and the box includes two cooking racks, two baking pans, a broiler rack, and a rotisserie kit that takes a 5-pound chicken. The rotisserie is a bonus, not the reason to buy this oven. The reason is two pizzas, one timer, everyone eating together.
It is a large machine. About 23 inches wide, 25 pounds, and it needs a long stretch of counter with air around it. If you cook pizza for a crowd, or you always want a second pie for the freezer, the size is the point. If you mostly cook one pizza for two people, it is more oven than you need, and the smaller ovens below are the better buy.
The best value pizza oven
A toaster oven for pizza does not need to be the most expensive oven on the page. It needs to fit a 12-inch pizza, heat it evenly, and get out of the way. The BLACK+DECKER Extra Wide does all three, and it costs less than the rest of this page. It was $86.87 and in stock as of Nov 18, 2026. That is the whole argument for it, and it is a good one.
The width is what you are buying. Eight slices of toast, a 12-inch pizza, and, most usefully, a standard 9-by-13 baking pan with the handles still on. For pizza night, the width means a 12-inch pie fits with air around it, and the convection fan moves the hot air around the crust so the edges brown at the same pace as the middle. The 60-minute timer has a stay-on setting for longer bakes, and there are three rack positions, so you can drop the rack low for a crisp base or raise it to brown the cheese. It runs on 1,500 watts, which leaves a little more headroom on the kitchen circuit than the 1,800-watt ovens here.
The interior is zinc-coated stainless steel, with no nonstick named. If the coating question matters to you, that is a genuine point in this oven's favour at this price. It is about 22 inches wide and weighs 17.5 pounds, so measure your counter before you buy it, and plan for it to live there. For a household that wants pizza night sorted without spending Breville money, this is the pick. It is also in my guide to the best toaster ovens under $100, where it leads the budget picks.
The one for big pizzas
Most frozen pizzas are 12 inches. Some are bigger. A take-and-bake from the store, a party pizza, or a homemade pie stretched wide can run to 14 inches, and a 14-inch pizza does not fit in a 12-inch oven. The Elite Gourmet ETO-4510M is the oven for the big pie. It fits two 14-inch pizzas at once, in a 47.5-quart box with four rack positions. If your household buys the big pizzas, this is the only oven on this page that takes them without a fight.
The French doors are the feature you notice first. Instead of a door that drops down toward you, hot glass and all, two doors swing open to the sides. You reach straight in with both hands and lift out a wide, heavy pizza without a hot door in the way. The controls are the surprise. Separate temperature dials for the top and bottom elements, each up to 450°F, so you can push the bottom heat for a crisp base without burning the cheese on top. For pizza, that control is exactly the right one. Convection evens the heat further, and there is a rotisserie in the box too.
One honest warning, because French doors have a history. The best-known French-door toaster oven, the Oster, was recalled in September 2025 after its spring-loaded doors snapped shut on people's hands. The Elite Gourmet is a different maker and a different door design, and it is not part of that recall. I would not buy an Oster French Door oven, new or second hand, without checking the model number against the recall first. The full story is in my guide to are toaster ovens safe.
The one with a door that rolls out of the way
Every toaster oven on this page except this one has a door that drops down toward you when you open it. That door is hot glass, and it hangs right where your hands go to reach the pizza. The Hamilton Beach Easy Reach solves it differently. The door rolls up and over the top of the oven, like a garage door, and stays out of the way. You reach straight in, and the counter in front of the oven stays clear.
That matters more than it sounds on pizza night. A pizza is wide, floppy, and hot, and you lift it out with two hands and a peel or a tray. A dropped-down door catches drips and crumbs, and it sits in the way when you lift. A door that rolls up keeps the counter clean and your hands clear. It is also the easiest door on this page for anyone who finds a heavy drop-down door awkward.
The oven itself is a solid middleweight. Convection, bake, broil, and toast, with two rack positions. It fits six slices, a 12-inch pizza, a 9-by-11 bake pan, or a 5-pound chicken. The temperature runs from 150°F to 450°F on 1,400 watts, and the 30-minute timer has auto shutoff and a stay-on setting. At 11.5 pounds it is the lightest full-size oven here, and the easiest to move. If your counter is small and your pizza is a standard 12 inches, this is the oven that fits the space and the job.
What makes a toaster oven good for pizza?
A pizza asks three things of an oven, and they are not the things that sell toaster ovens in a shop. The box talks about toast and presets. The pizza cares about heat from below, a high enough top temperature, and room to fit. Get those three right and the pizza comes out crisp. Get any one wrong and it comes out pale, soggy, or wedged against the walls.
Heat from below. A pizza base crisps from underneath. The bottom element does the real work, and the top element melts the cheese. An oven that only heats hard from the top will brown the cheese while the base stays pale and floppy. That is the most common pizza failure in a toaster oven, and it is a heat-balance problem, not a temperature problem. The Breville handles it by design: its Element IQ system sends more power to the bottom elements on the pizza preset. The Elite Gourmet handles it by hand: separate top and bottom dials, so you turn the bottom up yourself. On a simpler oven, the fix is the rack position. Put the pizza on the lowest rack, close to the bottom element, and the base gets the heat first.
A high enough top temperature. Frozen pizza boxes ask for 400°F to 450°F, and most of them say 425°F. Every oven on this page reaches 450°F, which is what you want. An oven that tops out at 400°F will still cook a frozen pizza, but it will take longer and the base will not crisp the same way. Temperature is not the whole story. A small cavity heats fast and holds its heat close to the food, which is why a toaster oven at 425°F crisps a base better than a big oven at the same setting. The heat is inches away, not a foot away.
Room to fit, with air around the pie. A pizza needs an inch of air around it for the hot air to move. A 12-inch pizza in a 12-inch cavity wedges against the walls, and the edges steam instead of crisping. That is why the Breville's 13-inch fit matters for a 12-inch pizza, and why the Elite Gourmet's 14-inch fit matters for a big take-and-bake. Measure the pizza you buy, then measure the rack. The rack is the real number, not the outside of the box.
Convection helps, and it changes the temperature. A fan moves hot air around the food, which cooks faster and more evenly. It matters most when two pizzas share the oven, because the fan keeps the top rack and the bottom rack cooking at the same pace. The rule for convection is simple: drop the box temperature by 25°F and check a few minutes early. If the box says 425°F, set a convection oven to 400°F. The pizza will cook in about the same time, with a more even crust.
The door matters more than the brochure admits. A pizza is wide, hot, and floppy. You lift it out with two hands, and a door that drops down toward you sits exactly where your hands go. The Hamilton Beach Easy Reach rolls its door up and out of the way. The Elite Gourmet swings its doors to the sides. The Breville, the BLACK+DECKER, and the Hamilton Beach rotisserie oven all have ordinary drop-down doors, and they work fine with an oven mitt and a peel. But if you have ever dropped a pizza on a hot door, you know why the door earns a line in a buying guide.
What about an air fryer oven? An air fryer oven is a toaster oven with a faster fan and an air fry setting, and it cooks a pizza well. The fan crisps the base fast, and the basket or tray holds a 12-inch pie. The trade is capacity and toast: a basket air fryer will not fit a whole pizza at all, and an oven-style fryer costs more than a plain toaster oven for the same pizza job. I put the full comparison in my guide to toaster oven vs air fryer, and the oven-style fryers are in my guide to the best air fryer ovens. If your kitchen already has an air fryer oven, it will handle pizza night. If you are buying one appliance for pizza, a toaster oven is the simpler buy.
How to cook a frozen pizza in a toaster oven
The box is the boss. Read it first, every time, because the temperature and time are written for that pizza, not for pizzas in general. Most frozen pizzas say 400°F to 450°F, and most of them say 425°F, for 12 to 20 minutes depending on thickness. A thin crust cooks in 10 to 12 minutes. A deep dish needs 18 to 25. The numbers below are the habits that make the box instructions work in a small oven.
Preheat, but not for long. A full-size oven needs 10 to 15 minutes to reach temperature. A toaster oven needs about 3 to 5 minutes, because the cavity is small. Turn it on while you unwrap the pizza and it will be ready when you are. Do not thaw the pizza first. Frozen pizza is made to cook from frozen, and a thawed pizza goes soggy before it goes crisp.
Put the pizza on the rack for a crisp base, on a pan for a soft one. This is the single biggest choice in frozen pizza, and the box often says so itself. Direct on the wire rack, the hot air reaches the base from below and the crust comes out crisp. On a baking sheet or pan, the base steams a little and stays softer. My house likes the rack. If your pizza has heavy toppings that might slide, a pan is the safer choice. Either way, use the middle rack for an even cook, or the lowest rack if the base needs more heat than the top.
Drop 25°F if the fan is on. Convection cooks faster than still air. If the box says 425°F and your oven has a convection setting, set 400°F and check a few minutes before the box time ends. The pizza will be done at about the same time, with a more even crust. The Breville does this for you on its pizza preset. On a dial oven, turn the dial yourself.
Check early the first time. Toaster ovens run hotter than their dials suggest, and the top element sits close to the food. Check the pizza a few minutes before the box time is up. Look for cheese that is melted and just starting to bubble, and a crust edge that is golden. If the cheese browns before the base crisps, lay a loose sheet of foil over the top and give the base a few more minutes. If the base is done and the cheese is pale, move the rack up one notch for the last two minutes.
Two pizzas need a swap. If you are cooking two pizzas at once in the Hamilton Beach 31103DA or the Elite Gourmet, swap the racks halfway through. The top pizza cooks faster near the top element. A halfway swap evens them out, and both come out at the same time. With convection on, the difference is smaller, but the swap still helps.
Let it rest for a minute. A pizza straight out of the oven is too hot to cut cleanly, and the cheese slides. One minute on the counter lets the cheese set. Two minutes is better if you can wait, which in my house nobody can.
What is the best toaster oven setting for reheating pizza?
Reheating is where a toaster oven earns its counter space. A microwave makes the crust rubbery. A full oven takes fifteen minutes to preheat for two slices. A toaster oven pizza reheat takes under ten minutes, with a crisp base and melted cheese, and it is the best tool in the kitchen for the job.
The setting is simple. Set the oven to 350°F on Bake, or use the Reheat function if your oven has one. The Breville has a reheat preset that skips the preheat and runs the fan gently. On a dial oven, Bake at 350°F does the same job. Turn the convection fan on if your oven has one, because the moving air warms the slice evenly and crisps the base faster.
The time depends on the crust. A thin-crust slice is ready in 4 to 5 minutes. A regular hand-tossed slice takes 5 to 8 minutes. A thick slice or a deep-dish wedge needs 8 to 10 minutes, because the middle has further to warm through. Start checking at 4 minutes, whatever the crust. A toaster oven's elements sit close to the food, so the top browns fast, and a slice can go from perfect to burnt in a minute.
Put the slice directly on the wire rack, not on a tray. The rack lets hot air reach the base from below, which is what re-crisps it. A tray insulates the base and leaves it soft. If the slice is floppy or the toppings are sliding, a piece of foil under it for the first few minutes helps, then slide it onto the bare rack to finish. Do not put a cup of water in the oven. Steam is the enemy of a crisp crust, and a wet oven makes a soft slice.
You do not need a long preheat for reheating. The small cavity comes up to temperature in a couple of minutes, and the slice warms through as the oven does. If you want the fastest result, put the slice in cold and set the timer for the full time. If you want the crispiest base, let the oven reach 350°F first, then put the slice in. Both work. The second one is a little better, and the first one is a little faster.
The safety number is 165°F. Leftovers should be reheated until they are steaming hot all the way through, and 165°F in the middle is the target. A slice that is hot on top and cool in the middle is not done yet. Give it two more minutes. Leftover pizza keeps 3 to 4 days in the fridge, and my guide to how long food lasts in the fridge and freezer has the full list of times. Get the leftover slices into the fridge within two hours of cooking, in a container or wrapped tight, and they will reheat well for days. My guide to how to store food so it lasts longer covers the habits that keep them good: cool food fast, seal it well, and keep the fridge cold.
Do you need a pizza stone in a toaster oven?
No, you do not need one. Every oven on this page cooks a good pizza without a stone. But a stone helps, and it is worth understanding why, because the same thinking applies to a steel pan or a heavy baking sheet.
A pizza stone is a slab of ceramic or cordierite that holds heat. You put it in the oven while the oven preheats, and by the time the pizza goes in, the stone is as hot as the oven. The pizza sits on the stone, and the stored heat crisps the base from below, fast. It is the closest a home oven gets to a pizzeria deck. The difference is real: a base cooked on a hot stone is crisper than a base cooked on a rack, because the stone gives the dough a blast of heat the moment it touches.
A toaster oven pizza stone is just a regular pizza stone sized to fit a small cavity. The catch is size. A stone has to fit inside the oven with air around it, and most pizza stones are made for a full-size oven. A 12-inch stone will not fit in an oven that fits a 12-inch pizza, because the stone needs the same inch of air the pizza does. Measure the rack, then buy a stone smaller than the rack, with at least an inch of space on every side. A rectangular stone often fits better than a round one in a toaster oven, because the cavity is wider than it is deep.
Two habits matter with a stone. First, heat it with the oven. Put the cold stone in a cold oven and let them warm up together. A cold stone dropped into a hot oven can crack from the shock, and a stone that is not fully hot does nothing for the base. Second, never wash a stone with soap. It is porous, and it holds what it soaks up. Scrape it clean when it is cool, wipe it with a damp cloth, and let the dark stains stay. A stained stone is a used stone, and it works better than a new one.
If you do not want a stone, a heavy baking sheet preheated in the oven does a similar job. Put the sheet in while the oven preheats, then slide the pizza onto the hot sheet. It is not as good as a stone, because steel holds less heat than ceramic, but it is better than a cold pan. A cast iron pan works too, if it fits. The principle is the same in every case: the base crisps against a hot surface, not against cold metal.
Is a toaster oven big enough for pizza?
The short answer is 12 inches. A standard frozen pizza is 12 inches across, and most take-and-bake pizzas from the store are 12 inches too. An oven that fits a 12-inch pizza covers pizza night for most households. Four of the five ovens on this page fit 12 inches or more. The fifth fits 11, and it gets its own section below.
The longer answer is that "fits a 12-inch pizza" is not one number. A toaster oven that can fit a pizza has to clear three: the rack width, the rack depth, and the height between the racks. A round pizza needs a rack that is at least 12 inches wide and 12 inches deep, with an inch of air on every side for the hot air to move. An oven that fits a 12-inch pizza on paper but wedges it against the walls will cook it unevenly, with pale edges where the air could not reach.
Measure before you buy, in two places. First, measure the pizza. The box tells you the size, but a tape measure on the frozen pie tells you the truth, because some pizzas run a little wide. Second, measure the rack inside the oven, or check the maker's listing for the pizza size it fits. The listings on this page are the maker's own numbers: the Breville fits 13 inches, the Hamilton Beach rotisserie oven fits two 12-inch pizzas, the BLACK+DECKER fits 12 inches, the Elite Gourmet fits two 14-inch pizzas, and the Hamilton Beach Easy Reach fits 12 inches.
If your household buys the big pizzas, size up. A 14-inch take-and-bake, a party pizza, or a homemade pie stretched wide needs the Elite Gourmet, because it is the only oven on this page that fits a 14-inch pizza. If your household eats personal pizzas, a smaller oven works, and the Cuisinart below is worth a look. Size the oven to the pizza you actually buy, not to the biggest pizza you might buy once a year.
Counter space is the other half of size. A toaster oven large enough for pizza is a wide machine. The BLACK+DECKER is about 22 inches wide, the Hamilton Beach rotisserie oven is about 23, and the Breville is about 19. Measure the counter where it will live, and leave a few inches of air above and behind it. A toaster oven vents hot air upward, and a cabinet jammed tight above it traps the heat. Keep two to four inches between the oven and the wall, and keep curtains, towels, and paper away from it.
The honest note about the 11-inch oven
The Cuisinart Custom Classic TOB-40N is a good oven. Three dials, no screen, nothing to learn. It toasts evenly, it bakes well, and the rack slides out on its own when you open the door. It costs $108.22 and was in stock as of Nov 18, 2026. It is in my main guide to the best toaster ovens as the simple pick, and it earns that place.
But it fits an 11-inch pizza, not a 12-inch one. A standard frozen pizza is 12 inches, and a 12-inch pizza does not fit in an 11-inch oven. That is the whole note, and it is why the Cuisinart is not one of the five picks on this page. If your household buys personal pizzas, or the smaller frozen pies, the Cuisinart is a fine choice. If you buy the standard 12-inch box, it is the wrong oven for pizza night, and no amount of good toast makes up for a pizza that does not fit.
I am saying this plainly because it is the easiest mistake to make with a toaster oven. The box says "fits a pizza" and the pizza in your freezer is an inch too wide. The fix is a tape measure and thirty seconds before you buy. If the Cuisinart is the oven you want for everything else, check the Cuisinart TOB-40N on Amazon and buy the 11-inch pizzas to match. Just go in knowing the number.
How to choose a toaster oven for pizza
Start with the pizza size. Count the inches first, then everything else. A 12-inch pizza is the standard, a 14-inch needs the Elite Gourmet, and an 11-inch fit is a different pizza night. Measure the pizza you buy, then buy the oven that fits it with air around it.
Heat from below matters most. A pizza base crisps from underneath. Look for an oven with bottom elements that pull their weight, a pizza preset that balances the heat, or separate top and bottom controls. The Breville and the Elite Gourmet both give you that control in different ways. On a simpler oven, the lowest rack position does the same job.
Convection is worth having for pizza. A fan evens the heat, which matters most when two pizzas share the oven or when the crust is thick. Four of the five ovens on this page have convection. The Cuisinart does not, and for a small pizza it does not need it. If you cook two pizzas at once, buy convection.
Wattage and your circuit. The ovens here draw between 1,400 and 1,800 watts. A standard kitchen circuit supplies about 1,800 watts. An 1,800-watt oven on the same circuit as a kettle will trip the breaker. Give the big ovens their own outlet. The Hamilton Beach Easy Reach at 1,400 watts and the BLACK+DECKER and Hamilton Beach rotisserie oven at 1,500 watts are the ones that share most happily.
Dials or digital. Dials are simple, last forever, and need no reading. Digital controls give you presets, a timer you can see, and precise temperatures. The Breville is digital. The rest of this page is dials. Neither is better. Pick the one you will use at 6pm when you are tired.
The door is a pizza feature. A pizza is wide, hot, and floppy, and you lift it out with two hands. A roll-top door or French doors keep the way clear. A drop-down door works fine with an oven mitt and a peel, but it is the one part of the oven you touch every single time you cook.
Coatings and the non-toxic question. Most toaster oven interiors are nonstick, and the coating is usually PTFE. PTFE is stable and inert below 500°F, and it does not react with food or release anything into it. Pizza cooks at 400°F to 450°F, which is inside that safe range. The trouble starts above 500°F, where the coating begins to break down, and a scratched or flaking coating is past its life whatever the temperature. The BLACK+DECKER on this page has a zinc-coated stainless interior with no nonstick named. If coatings are the deciding question, my guide to the best non-toxic toaster ovens covers the ovens without one in full.
Recalls. Check the model number before you buy, new or second hand. The recall is always tied to a specific model, not a brand. The Oster French Door recall and the Panasonic NB-G200 recall are both covered in my guide to are toaster ovens safe, along with fire habits and the radiation question. Register the oven with the maker when you buy it, so a recall notice reaches you.
Care habits that keep it working. Empty the crumb tray often, because crumbs in the tray are fuel and cheese drips burn onto the bottom. Wipe the interior while it is warm, not hot, with a damp cloth. Never use steel wool inside, because it scratches the coating. Skip the aerosol spray, because spray oils leave a residue that bakes onto coatings and glass and will not come off. Unplug the oven when you are done, and let it cool first.
Questions people ask
Can a toaster oven fit a pizza?
Yes, if you buy the right size. A standard frozen pizza is 12 inches, and four of the five ovens on this page fit 12 inches or more. The Breville fits 13 inches and the Elite Gourmet fits two 14-inch pizzas. Measure the pizza, then measure the rack.
What is the best toaster oven for frozen pizza?
The Breville Smart Oven BOV800XL. A 13-inch fit, a pizza preset, and heat control that sends more power to the bottom elements, so the base crisps while the cheese melts. The convection fan keeps the crust even from edge to middle.
What is the best toaster oven for large pizza?
The Elite Gourmet ETO-4510M French Door Convection Oven. It fits two 14-inch pizzas, the biggest fit on this page, with separate top and bottom temperature controls so you can crisp the base without burning the cheese.
What is the best toaster oven for 12 inch pizza?
Any oven on this page except the Cuisinart TOB-40N, which fits 11 inches. The BLACK+DECKER TO3250XSB is the best value for a 12-inch pizza, and the Hamilton Beach 31103DA fits two 12-inch pizzas at once.
Can you cook a pizza in a toaster oven?
Yes. Follow the box instructions, usually 425°F for 12 to 20 minutes, and drop 25°F if the convection fan is on. Put the pizza directly on the rack for a crisp base, or on a pan for a softer one. Check a few minutes early the first time.
What is the best toaster oven setting for pizza?
Bake at the temperature on the box, usually 425°F, with the convection fan on if your oven has one. If your oven has a pizza preset, use it. The Breville's pizza preset balances the top and bottom heat for you.
What is the best toaster oven setting for reheating pizza?
Bake at 350°F, or the Reheat function if your oven has one. A thin slice takes 4 to 5 minutes, a regular slice 5 to 8 minutes, and a thick slice 8 to 10 minutes. Put the slice directly on the rack and start checking at 4 minutes.
How long does it take to reheat pizza in a toaster oven?
Most slices are ready in 5 to 8 minutes at 350°F. Thin crust is faster, 4 to 5 minutes. Deep dish is slower, 8 to 10 minutes. The slice is done when the cheese is melted and the base is crisp, and the middle is steaming hot.
Do I need a pizza stone in a toaster oven?
No, but a stone helps the base crisp. It has to fit with at least an inch of air on every side, and it must heat up with the oven from cold. A preheated heavy baking sheet does a similar job if you do not want a stone.
Is a toaster oven better than an air fryer for pizza?
For a whole pizza, yes. A toaster oven fits a 12-inch pie and toasts, bakes, and roasts. A basket air fryer will not fit a whole pizza at all. An oven-style air fryer cooks a pizza well, and the full comparison is in my guide to toaster oven vs air fryer.
How long does leftover pizza keep?
Leftover pizza keeps 3 to 4 days in the fridge, in a container or wrapped tight. Get it into the fridge within two hours of cooking. My guide to how long food lasts in the fridge and freezer has the full list of times for leftovers.
Can you put foil in a toaster oven?
Yes, with care. Use it to cover food, not to line the crumb tray or cover the whole rack. Foil that touches a heating element can melt or catch fire, and foil covering the rack blocks the air that convection needs. Keep at least an inch between foil and the elements.
The bottom line
If you buy one toaster oven for pizza, buy the Breville Smart Oven BOV800XL. It is the most even pizza cooking on this page, the pizza preset does the heat balancing for you, and a 13-inch fit means a 12-inch pizza cooks with air around it. It is the oven I would hand to anyone starting out.
If you feed a crowd, buy the Hamilton Beach 31103DA instead. Two 12-inch pizzas at once, one timer, and everyone eats together. If your household buys the big pizzas, buy the Elite Gourmet ETO-4510M, the only oven here that fits a 14-inch pie.
If your budget is the deciding factor, buy the BLACK+DECKER TO3250XSB. A 12-inch pizza, eight slices, and a 9-by-13 pan with handles, for $86.87 as of Nov 18, 2026. And if the door is the thing that bothers you, the Hamilton Beach 31123DA Easy Reach rolls its door up and out of the way.
And if you buy nothing, you still have the useful part. Measure the pizza before you buy the oven. Heat the base from below. Drop 25°F when the fan is on. Reheat at 350°F and check at 4 minutes. Empty the crumb tray, and unplug the oven when you are done. Those habits are worth more than any preset, and Tuesday pizza night will be better for them.